2013-04-17 / Columnists

Pets pets pets

Does neutering affect certain dogs’ health; possibly contributing to cases of cancer and joint disease? The following study from the University of California Davis is something to ponder. It may make veterinarians rethink an altering timeline for certain breeds of dogs.

The dog overpopulation crisis forces euthanasia at shelters across the US. Therefore, this research is not going to sit well with shelter rescue advocates because traditional spaying and neutering of dogs at six months old has long been the crusade of the rescue world which later embraced pediatric spay/neuter (aka “early” spay/neuter) when this method became available in the 1980s for pups that were as young as seven weeks. The following excerpt is verbatim from the 2/13/13 UC Davis press release:

“Neutering, and the age at which a dog is neutered, may affect the animal’s risk for developing certain cancers and joint diseases, according to a new study of golden retrievers by a team of researchers at the University of California, Davis.

The study, which examined the health records of 759 golden retrievers, found a surprising doubling of hip dysplasia among male dogs neutered before one year of age. This and other results were published Feb. 13 in the online scientific journal PLOS ONE.

“The study results indicate that dog owners and service dog trainers should carefully consider when to have their male or female dogs neutered,” said lead investigator Benjamin Hart, a distinguished professor emeritus in the UC Davis School of Veterinary Medicine.

“It is important to remember, however, that because different dog breeds have different vulnerabilities to various diseases, the effects of early and late neutering also may vary from breed to breed,” he said.

While results of the new study are revealing, Hart said the relationship between neutering and disease-risk remains a complex issue. For example, the increased incidence of joint diseases among early-neutered dogs is likely a combination of the effect of neutering on the young dog’s growth plates as well as the increase in weight on the joints that is commonly seen in neutered dogs.

Dog owners in the United States are overwhelmingly choosing to neuter their dogs, in large part to prevent pet overpopulation or avoid unwanted behaviors. In the U.S., surgical neutering - known as spaying in females - is usually done when the dog is less than one year old. {My two cents- spaying a female before her first heat is often recommended because this reduces the chance of her developing mammary tumors later in life.}

In Europe, however, neutering is generally avoided by owners and trainers and not promoted by animal health authorities, Hart said.

During the past decade, some studies have indicated that neutering can have several adverse health effects for certain dog breeds. Those studies examined individual diseases using data drawn from one breed or pooled from several breeds.

Against that backdrop, Hart and colleagues launched their study, using a single hospital database. The study was designed to examine the effects of neutering on the risks of several diseases in the same breed, distinguishing between males and females and between early or late neutering and non-neutering.

The researchers chose to focus on the golden retriever because it is one of the most popular breeds in the U.S. and Europe and is vulnerable to various cancers and joint disorders. The breed also is favored for work as a service dog.

The research team reviewed the records of female and male golden retrievers, ranging in age from one to eight years, that had been examined at UC Davis’ William R. Pritchard Veterinary Medical Teaching Hospital for two joint disorders and three cancers: hip dysplasia, cranial cruciate ligament tear, lymphosarcoma, hemangiosarcoma and mast cell tumor. The dogs were classified as intact (not neutered), neutered early (before 12 months of age) or neutered late (at or after 12 months of age).

Joint disorders and cancers are of particular interest because neutering removes the male dog’s testes and the female’s ovaries, interrupting production of certain hormones that play key roles in important body processes such as closure of bone growth plates, and regulation of the estrous cycle in female dogs.

The study revealed that, for all five diseases analyzed, the disease rates were significantly higher in both males and females that were neutered either early or late compared with intact (non-neutered) dogs.

Specifically, early neutering was associated with an increase in the occurrence of hip dysplasia, cranial cruciate ligament tear and lymphosarcoma in males and of cranial cruciate ligament tear in females. Late neutering was associated with the subsequent occurrence of mast cell tumors and hemangiosarcoma in females.

In most areas, the findings of this study were consistent with earlier studies, suggesting similar increases in disease risks. The new study, however, was the first to specifically report an increased risk of late neutering for mast cell tumors and hemangiosarcoma.

Furthermore, the new study showed a surprising 100 percent increase, or doubling, of the incidence of hip dysplasia among early-neutered males. Earlier studies had reported a 17 percent increase among all neutered dogs compared to all non-neutered dogs, indicating the importance of the new study in making gender and ageof neutering comparisons.”

According to AKC Canine Health Foundation, “the task is now to determine if the observations in this study are indeed true across all breeds and mixed breeds of dogs. Dr. Hart is interested in continuing his work by studying Labrador Retrievers, German Shepherd Dogs and Dachshunds. Additionally, gaps in knowledge continue to exist concerning the complex relationship between sex hormones and cancer.”

Dr. Christine Zink is a professor of pathology and microbiology at John Hopkins who has done extensive research on HIV; but as a veterinarian, she treats agility dogs. She raises questions in her thought-provoking 2005 article “Early Spay-Neuter Considerations for the Canine Athlete” which is available online. She mentions studies where dogs spayed or neutered early are taller than dogs spayed at an older age. Zink notes that sex hormones have a role in bone density, concluding that this may be the reason veterinarians are seeing a higher incidence of orthopedic disease in dogs altered early. She also offers interesting suggestions balancing the rescue/ overpopulation dilemma with decision making in the hands of responsible dog owners as to the best age to spay/neuter their dogs.

Babylon Town Shelter Adoptables (631-643-9270) Lamar St. W. Babylon: Showcasing two tiny dogs that each need a change of fortune. Poodle mix “Lucky” #13-211 isn’t so lucky. He was returned to the shelter after two years because of landlord woes. Min Pin “Chino” #13-209 may have been abandoned when his former owners moved. Come meet all the dogs and cats waiting at the shelter.

Return to top